LetterVed 18.11.2026

Culture wars

• •

Sharp Gallic meaning

The modern wars in literary theory began to rage in the 1960s, when a wave of revolutions and student strikes engulfed virtually the entire West. Poststructuralism, once considered a high-brow theory born in the quiet of a backroom, in reality turned out to be a well-designed war machine. Its weapons were aimed primarily at structuralism and the traditional Sorbonne, particularly the followers of Gustave Lanson, who prioritized literary history and believed that literature should be studied within the context of culture and society. As it developed, poststructuralism waged war against everything: order and center, logos and phallus, and so on.

Roland Barthes

A leftist, nonconformist impulse is clearly expressed in Roland Barthes's early work, Mythologies (1957), written before the poststructuralist period. It is a protest against hierarchy, the domination of power, and the manipulation of society through words. «Mythologies» was written over a period of about two years. At the same time, Barthes wrote a column for the newspaper Lettres nouvelles, where he discussed everything from celebrity weddings to seasonal vegetable sales to new cleaning products. He collected the most successful of these articles under a single cover and concluded the book with a conceptual afterword, «Myth Today,» which argued that myth is a stolen and reclaimed word, used to deprive us of the primary meaning of things and replace it with another. After reading «Mythologies,» it becomes clear that the main enemy of any left-thinking Frenchman is the bourgeoisie, who hold power and control the mass consciousness.

The same rebellious ideas about the destruction of all hierarchy were embedded in Julia Kristeva's concept of «carnival,» in the ideas of Lacan, who attacked the patriarchy of classical Freudian psychoanalysis, and Jacques Derrida, who believed that any attempts to impose order and establish some kind of hierarchy in our world, where there is nothing but an endless teeming diversity, are doomed to failure. Michel Foucault, with his idea of the «shadow» of the episteme, is also worth mentioning here. An episteme is a specific system of ordered representations that appears entirely logical, thereby securing a dominant position, allowing it to forcibly exclude certain phenomena and facts that do not fit into this system. But what is repressed, denied, and silenced gradually forms a «shadow» that destroys the episteme.

The poet Timur Kibirov captured the spirit of poststructuralism's anti-bourgeois ideology very well. He compared the «sharp Gallic sense» to a Finnish knife, and the pens used to write scientific papers to «pens» driven into the ribs:

We don't say discourse, we say discurs!
And the suckers who don't give a damn,
tremble and fade instantly,
and the most impudent joker goes deaf!

And like a Finnish knife, a sharp Gallic meaning
He'll pee right away whoever starts acting up!
And there are enough feathers to scratch everyone!
Filter your words, filter your words, baby.

Young America

In the 1960s, the New Left movement emerged, opposing the Old Left—the traditional communist parties and social democrats. They rejected the Marxist idea of the need to first change the material basis and social order, which would subsequently lead to changes in people's consciousness. According to the New Left, it was necessary to begin with human consciousness. During this decade, a powerful wave of protests swept across the West. Young people rebelled against the older generation, students demanded reform of the education system, feminists, and racial and national minorities declared their rights. Left-wing academic ideologists joined the protest movement: Herbert Marcuse, a professor at the University of California at San Diego, with his famous books One-Dimensional Man (1964) and Repressive Tolerance (1965); Theodore Roszak, a professor at the University of California at Berkeley and author of the monograph «The Making of the Counterculture» (1969); Charles Reich, who summed up the events of the 1960s with his work «Young America» (1969).

Wright Mills

At the time, sit-ins were common: students would occupy rector's offices, dean's offices, or classrooms and refuse to leave until their demands were met. Teach-ins, which were not approved by university administration, were also common. Protesters would invite individuals they found interesting to universities to give seminars or lectures. Among them were Che Guevara, countercultural university professor Wright Mills, known for his books White Collar: The American Middle Class (1951) and Listen, Yankee: Revolution in Cuba (1960), and Frantz Fanon, who addressed racial discrimination and advocated for decolonization in the Third World, which later made him a pillar of postcolonial thought.

In 1960, the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee emerged in the United States, its core members consisting of sit-in activists. At the same time, Students for a Democratic Society was formed, and in 1962, its members adopted the Port Huron Declaration, which spoke, among other things, of the need for changes in the education system.

The combined efforts of rebellious students and faculty led to a reform that created a new university and academic reality that persists to this day. It all began at the University of California, Berkeley, where the Free Speech Movement emerged in the spring of 1965 in response to the university administration's ban on distributing political literature on campus. Following negotiations with the administration, it was decided to revise the existing curriculum and system of instruction. This gave rise to the phenomenon of "studies"—research devoted to pressing social issues. These were interdisciplinary programs that brought together specialists from various humanities disciplines—sociologists, historians, economists, and philosophers—to study various pressing issues and seek solutions.

New players

Elaine Showalter

Women's studies emerged at Cornell University in 1969, and the following year, the initiative was picked up by the University of California, San Diego. The discipline's development is described by Elaine Showalter, one of the founders of Anglo-American literary criticism, in her article «Our Criticism, Autonomy, and the Assimilation of African-American and Feminist Literary Theory» (1989). Initially, the goal of women's studies was to combat androgynous poetics, which, incidentally, still has many adherents among women scholars and writers. The androgynous approach implied that there is no male or female in literature, only good and bad writers. But Showalter saw this as deceitful and manipulative, as male writing and male-dominated research remained the norm.

The women's movement of the late 1960s gave rise to feminist critiques of male culture and feminine aesthetics, and by the mid-1970s, academic feminist criticism, in concert with interdisciplinary feminist studies, entered a new phase of «gynocriticism,» or the study of women's writing. Showalter called this period «a phase of intellectual rebellion, gynocentrism, and critical separatism,» when women insisted on their otherness and engaged in hostility with men. She also mentioned prominent feminists of the period: Hélène Cixous, Luce Irigaray, Julia Kristeva, Julia Penelope Stanley, Susan Wolf, and others. However, over time, militant leftist sentiments began to wane, and the phenomenon of gynocriticism emerged, followed by the emergence of gender studies, which also examined male identity.

The French theorist Jacques Lacan, who opposed the ideas of Sigmund Freud, became a favorite of feminists. Freud, as is well known, built his theory around the phallus and believed that women were tormented by «penis envy.» Lacan argued that, in fact, the biological, emotional, and intellectual makeup of every human being is constituted by «need/lack» (le manque à être), i.e., the ontological experience of incompleteness that arises at the moment of separation of the child from the mother's body. Nowhere except in the womb can a person experience the fullest ontological pleasure of undisturbed security and wholeness. This compels people—especially men—to constantly strive to fill the void created by birth. Thus, unlike Freud, Lacan prioritized the woman as a mother.

Nathan Hare

African-American studies emerged almost simultaneously with women's studies. Its founder, Nathan Hare, a professor of sociology at the University of California, San Francisco, proposed testing his concept with the Black Student Union, an organization formed in March 1966 at the same university. The idea was supported and submitted to the university administration for consideration. In January 1969, African-American studies was founded at the University of California, Berkeley. Its result was the idea that African-American literature represents a self-contained, separate world, virtually independent of the surrounding white American literature and culture. Completely autonomous, it is built on topoi, mythologemes, and ideas imported from Africa. In this sense, African-American literature surpassed other ethnic American literatures that subsequently followed in its footsteps.

The captivating myth of a distinctive and self-sufficient «black aesthetic» was developed by literary theorists Robert Steptoe, Houston Baker, and Henry Louis Gates. Their theory contradicted traditional views of African-American writers as specifically American. This formed the basis of postcolonial ideas developed by Edward Said and other theorists. One of these was the idea of the «two-voice» of racial and ethnic minorities, who write simultaneously for the entire nation and only for «their own,» coding their speech so that every word can be understood in two ways.

It's important to note that the aforementioned Showalter, Steptoe, Baker, Gates, and other active academics arrived at universities in the 1960s and found themselves in a traditional education system that offered little promise for their success. For example, Baker, one of the most militant and even controversial ideologists of African-American studies, began his career in the university's English department, where he was offered the opportunity to study traditional Western culture, history, and literature—Shakespeare, Dickens, Wilde, and others—with white professors. He diligently completed all the required academic requirements, earned a bachelor's degree, then a master's degree, and began considering a doctorate. Baker was well aware that, as a native of Kentucky and from a very poor family, he was incredibly fortunate to have found himself at the university. But he could not count on a brilliant academic career, since competing with the so-called white Anglo-Saxon male Protestants in the field of Shakespearean or Dickensian studies was a losing proposition.

However, those who had been relegated to the margins of academic life soon had a chance to assert themselves. In the 1970s, feminist scholarship and African-American literary theory and criticism began to gain a foothold in universities. Now, faculty in these new disciplines could secure teaching hours, create their own programs, recruit students, and hope for grants. But this lucrative piece of the academic pie came with a price. Figuring that the best defense is a good offense, young scholars began attacking the traditional education system, arguing that Shakespeare, Dante, Dickens, and other authors, who were given astronomical amounts of time, should step aside and make way for something new—for example, African-American literature and women writers.

Black and white

Naturally, the new studies immediately found opponents, who advocated the preservation of traditional programs and research priorities. They sought to protect «great literature» from the onslaught of new authors, and also defended their own academic hours devoted to European classics.

Houston Baker

In the 1980s, this conflict erupted into a full-blown culture war. Houston Baker published a number of works, of which «Modernism and the Harlem Renaissance» (1989) received the most vigorous reviews. Here's what Baker wrote about Fitzgerald's «The Great Gatsby»:

«Civilization is falling apart,„ Tom Buchanan confides at a dinner party he's throwing at his palatial mansion on Long Island... Tom's pessimism has its roots in books. It echoes the racist mutterings of Stoddard (Lothrop Stoddard, a eugenicist and racial theorist. - O.P.). In fact, it is not the citadel of civilization that is under threat, but the dominance of white Anglo-Saxon males with their brazen racism, open sexism, and incredible wealth.».

In response to this bold attack, the renowned scholar of literary modernism and author of the authoritative monograph The Harlem Renaissance in Black and White (1995), Professor of English Literature George Hutchinson, stated that black supporters of Afrocentrism incorrectly interpret not only white Anglo-Saxon culture, but also their own:

«Gates and Baker define the African-American tradition in a way that the Harlem Renaissance writers consciously rejected... I will not dispute the value of such inventions, but I will defend the value of a balanced historical approach, detailed and nuanced, that studies the writers in the context of the field in which they actually worked.».

George Hutchinson

In his monograph, Hutchinson presented numerous reliable facts proving that the authors of the 1920s, whom Baker and Gates presented as Afrocentrists who rejected and stigmatized the white American tradition, in fact sought to incorporate themselves into American national culture in such a way as not to lose their own originality, but to become an organic part of the pan-American national tradition, to decorate and enrich it.

A common theme among African-American theorists was the assertion that the voice of their people had been silenced throughout the history of American literature, culture, and society as a whole. The renowned American scholar Dixon Bruce Jr., who studied Southern history and considered the cultural and literary history of African Americans his minor specialty, disputed this assertion in the preface to his book, The Origins of African-American Literature, 1680–1865 (2001). An unrivaled connoisseur of archives and old press publications, Bruce pored over a vast amount of material and, with facts in hand, demonstrated that the voices of African-American thinkers, writers, and public figures were clearly audible in both the 18th and 19th centuries, and that no significant press discussion on race occurred without contributions from representatives of the Black race. Thus, proponents of Afrocentrism found powerful opponents in the form of serious scholars whose primary concern was the pursuit of scientific truth.

Allan Bloom

Among the participants in the «culture wars» of the late 20th century was Indiana native Allan Bloom, a philosopher, classicist, and student of Leo Strauss, Alexandre Kojève, and the renowned American civil rights activist Richard McKeown. In 1987, he published The End of the American Mind, the subtitle of which read: «How Higher Education Has Failed Democracy and Is Impoverishing the Souls of Today's Students.» In this work, Bloom railed against moral relativism and the imposition of new prejudices, criticizing higher education as well as contemporary trends in philosophy and the humanities in general. The book consists of three parts: «Students,» «Nihilism: American Style,» and «The University.» In the first part, the author lamented that young people enter universities completely unprepared, lacking the necessary background knowledge. He also discussed the problem of «great Western books,» which are about to be removed from the curriculum. In the second part, Bloom wrote about «value relativism» and criticized both positivists for their reluctance to humanize ethical and political issues, and deconstructionists and all «new left» scholars for their skepticism, rationalism, and discrediting of basic moral imperatives. As a result, Bloom argued, a void emerges, easily filled by the demagoguery of left-wing or right-wing radicals who pose as academic teachers and researchers but are, in fact, politically engaged radicals. They seek to recruit followers by making students fanatics of this or that idea, teaching them not to reason but to blindly believe in the slogans they are fed under the guise of «teaching.» In the final part, Bloom expressed dissatisfaction with contemporary liberal education, which represented a «mixture of skepticism, moralism, and cowardice.» According to Bloom, the main thing that drives universities is the desire to avoid problems and maintain their reputation. And the only value they unconditionally uphold and promise to students is success and prosperity—that is, careers and money.

Allan Bloom's book unexpectedly became a bestseller. It received numerous critical reviews, both strongly negative and positive. Art critic Roger Kimble responded with a rave in the New York Times, calling Bloom's work «a magnificent description of the degenerating moral and intellectual climate that reigns in American universities and education.» Interestingly, the book was also praised by Norman Podhoretz, a figure of the «Old Left» who had embraced neoconservative positions by the late 1960s. He noted that the collapse of the intellectual horizon described by Bloom was, paradoxically, the flip side of the openness to new ideas and trends constantly preached in academia. This paved the way for a new dogmatism, narrow-minded and utterly intolerant of the opinions of others. Poet Frederick Turner called The End of the American Mind «the most thoughtful and penetrating analysis of the ills that plague our intellectual and moral life, especially in the university.» The book was also praised by feminist Camille Paglia, who called Bloom's work «the opening shot in the culture war that has begun.».

Allan Bloom's detractors considered him a die-hard conservative. Among them were philosopher and University of Chicago law and ethics professor Martha Nussbaum, essayist and political analyst David Rieff, and writer, biographer, editor, and critic James Atlas, who published a review in the New York Times Magazine titled «The Grumpy Chicago Guru»—as he called Bloom—and compiled all the negative reviews of the controversial book that had been published to that point.

The Curse of Political Correctness

Harold Bloom

In 1994, Allan Bloom's namesake, Harold Bloom, published The Western Canon: Books and Schools Through the Ages, in which he polemicized against a leftist front of scholars and educators he dubbed the «school of ressentiment» or «school of revenge.» He included in this «school» feminist criticism, poststructuralism (in particular, the ideas of Lacan, Derrida, and Foucault), postcolonial criticism, African-American and Asian-American criticism, the «new historicism,» neo-Marxism—in short, the entire left front. Bloom believed that all these movements stemmed from a common root and pursued the same goal: to push their agenda at the expense of aesthetic and moral values. He argued that, being politically and socially active, these individuals were willing to use any means necessary to establish themselves within the university environment and recruit as many adherents as possible by converting students to their faith. Thus, the «school of resentment» discredits the «Western canon,» allegedly based on racist and sexist notions. At best, revanchists will attempt to expand the canon at the expense of their own authors, with little regard for their artistic achievements; at worst, they will dismantle it entirely. Speaking of the «Western canon,» Bloom identified 26 «untouchable» figures, including Dante Alighieri, Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, Jane Austen, Emily Dickinson, Sigmund Freud, Virginia Woolf, Franz Kafka, and others. Shakespeare was declared the center of the canon.

Like «The End of the American Mind,» «The Western Canon» sparked widespread public attention. Harold Bloom's ideas were enthusiastically endorsed by writer and journalist Adam Bigley in a review published in the New York Times:

«Bloom's notion of artistic originality contradicts egalitarianism. Few achieve it; few appreciate it. But great literature, Bloom insists, has nothing to do with social justice… This is the curse of political correctness. In The Western Canon, Bloom seeks to uncover the undercurrent of the school of resentment… Who are Bloom's enemies, and what is their credo? In the book, he mentions Derrida, Foucault, and Lacan—that powerful triumvirate of French theorists—though he doesn't say directly what these names mean to him. But anyone who understands the culture wars can decipher what's written between the lines.

Another prominent thinker, Stephen Hicks, exposed the «manipulators and Machiavellians of the left» in an article inspired by «The Western Canon.» Specifically, he criticized the views of renowned feminist scholar Kate Ellis, who, however, openly stated that the application of poststructuralist methods should be a weapon against outdated notions. Hicks spoke of the danger posed by such an approach:

«When a professor pursues political goals, the main obstacle they face is the magnificent books created by brilliant minds on the other side of the fence... Therefore, if you're a left-wing graduate student or professor who has to deal with the Western literary canon, you have two options. You can take up the challenge, let your students read these great books, discuss them, and debate them in class. But this is very difficult and very risky, because students might side with the other side. Or you can simply set the tradition aside and teach only those books that align with your political convictions... Deconstruction allows you to dismiss an entire literary tradition as built on racism, sexism, or similar forms of exploitation. It provides the basis for simply setting that tradition aside.».

When discussing Harold Bloom's supporters, it's also worth mentioning the renowned literary critic and translator Barbara Johnson. She spoke out against Gates and other proponents of Afrocentric theory, accusing them of forcing African Americans back into ghettos and attempting to construct a closed universe of Black culture, thereby excluding them from the common cultural space. «Culture knows neither apartheid nor separatism,» Johnson wrote.

Another Renaissance

Louis Monrose

But the left front had something to say in response to the conservatives. In the second half of the 1980s, the «new historicism» began to develop—a scholarly movement, largely neo-Marxist, that also aimed to defend the rights of those previously silenced: women, racial and ethnic minorities, marginalized groups, and so on. The «new historians» took up arms against the «Boston Brahmins»—the eminent figures of American academia, who were, in fact, mostly based at Yale, not Boston. It's important to mention here the article «Studying the Renaissance: The Poetics and Politics of Culture» by University of California, San Diego professor Louis Monrose. It was published in the collection «The New Historicism» in 1989 and became a kind of manifesto for the movement.

At the beginning of the article, Monrose takes aim at James Hillis Miller, a literary critic, Yale deconstructionist, and chairman of one of the most influential academic bodies in the United States, the Modern Language Association. For Monrose, Miller embodies the «Boston Brahmins»—the notorious «white Anglo-Saxon Protestants,» traditionalists, and neoconservatives desperately trying to maintain their position in academia. In «Studying the Renaissance...» we read:

«In his 1986 chairman's address, Miller noted with some alarm and a certain amount of exaggeration that „in recent years, literary studies has seen a sudden, almost universal abandonment of theory in the sense of focusing on language as such, and an equally universal turn toward history, culture, society, politics, institutions, class and gender conditions, social context, and the material basis.“ With this formulation, Miller pits the linguistic and the social against each other. Miller categorically contrasts „reading“ with cultural criticism, and „theory“ with the discourses of cultural history, society, politics, institutions, class, and gender.».

Continuing to blame Miller, Montrose wrote:

«Miller completely equates „theory“ with the most distilled, politically emasculated forms of deconstruction. Only these are ethically and cognitively laudable; Miller dismisses everything else as „ideology,“ and ideology, for him, is a state infected with biases and illusions, a state in which, according to Miller, both so-called left-wing and so-called right-wing critics, deconstruction's antagonists, reside.
And thus Miller indiscriminately lumps together all representatives of the academic world, all bearers of a critical spirit, but this is nothing more than deceit, manipulation, and fraud. Because „theory“ doesn't float serenely above „ideology,“ but rather sinks knee-deep into it...»

Montrose then offered his alternative definition of ideology:

«Ideology is what enables people to engage in meaningful social action in a meaningful social world... in this understanding, our professional practice is the production of ideology. Professorial activity not only passively reflects the professor's values, beliefs, and experiences... it actively represents these values, beliefs, and experiences to the audience.». Monrose exposes the ideological essence of this supra-ideological soaring in the empyrean of pure theory. In his view, Miller attempts to present his «pure theory» as the quintessence of the concept of «science,» declaring its non-ideological nature, insisting that «pure science» should not cede its territory to partisan political agendas. But in reality, Miller simply wants to cement the status quo, the dominance of «white Anglo-Saxon male Protestants» in the academic world, and to claim that only he and others like him are engaged in genuine science beyond ideology, beyond any political agenda. However, such «non-ideological» approach is a protective, conservative ideology (just as «androgynous poetics» is, in essence, a «masculine» poetics).

In his article, Monrose attempted to thwart the aspirations of the «new Brahmins.» He positioned Allan Bloom as an ideological enemy and also quoted William Bennett, director of the National Endowment for the Humanities. In 1984, Bennett published an article, «Higher Education in America,» in which he agreed that universities had become more accessible to members of minority groups and were eager to embrace new values and trends, but he noted that the ideas of the great minds of Western civilization should still be preserved and defended. «All these conservatives, striving to maintain their dominant position,» wrote Monrose, "are trying to banish politics, partisanship, and a relevant agenda from the universities. But in reality, our universities and our teaching are woven into what I will call the politics of culture." The article concluded:

«It's believed that our primary task as teachers and scholars is to question the legacy we're paid to preserve and transmit. But the left views literature as a fluid arena for the struggle between verbal and social practices.».

Montrose then appealed to his like-minded people to «resist that regime of power and knowledge which does not so much support us as fetters us.».

«New historians» like Montrose and especially Stephen Greenblatt sought to reclaim the English Renaissance from the highbrow «Brahmins» and engage Shakespeare in their own way, demonstrating how he reflects issues of race, gender, and the social underclass. In other words, they interpreted the pillars of European classicism in a contemporary context, not the era in which these authors lived and wrote. For example, when Stephen Greenblatt analyzed Othello, he was not really talking about Shakespeare, but about the racial and gender issues of contemporary America. Greenblatt's Iago is a manipulator with the consciousness of a colonialist, who hates Othello for infiltrating a white male world and assuming a commanding position there. Therefore, he destroys his marriage to Desdemona, a white woman who disgraced herself by marrying a Black man. Iago thus manages to construct a new narrative in which Othello emerges as a barbarian, a second-class citizen, full of self-loathing and hatred for his own wife, whom he ultimately murders. To some extent, one can understand the outrage of Allan and Harold Bloom, who saw such studies as an attack on Shakespeare by introducing political bias into academic programs under the guise of science.

But no matter how fierce these cultural wars were, let's not discount academic pragmatism. Alongside the struggle for literature, there was a struggle for hours, students, and, of course, grants. As Timur Kibirov wrote:

Why are you whining, why are you howling,
what are you croaking in the night,
Why are you whining, you zealous one?
with a stupid head
dreaming of concluding a pact!

Why are you begging, you beggar!
We are not locals, you and I,
and, admit it without hiding,
our stories are outdated
in a quiet coffin cell

about the high and the beautiful,
Schiller-Schmiller, old Dante...
Your efforts are in vain,
your machinations are dangerous,
obscurantist and obscurantist!

In short, it's a piece of cake, not a grant!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *