Evgeny Tsurkan. The Philosophy of Horror. What Frightens Us in the World and in Ourselves. Moscow: Led; AST, 2026.
On January 4, 1960, Albert Camus was returning from Provence to Paris. He had intended to travel by train, but at the last minute accepted an invitation from his friend and publisher, Michel Gallimard, to join him in a luxurious Facel Vega. On a straight stretch of road near Villeblevin, the car skidded off the road and crashed into a plane tree. Camus died instantly; Gallimard died a few days later. An unused train ticket was found in the writer's pocket—a small paper document of another, now impossible, future. Camus, who, not without pride, called himself a «free shooter» at his Nobel Prize acceptance speech, refused throughout his life to choose sides or align himself with either of the warring camps. An eternal loner, he constructed a Robinsonade of meaning in a silent world. Rebellion, for him, was a way to live without ultimate justification. This solitary rebellion ended with his impact with a tree. Yes, man is mortal, but that would have been only half the trouble. The bad thing is that he is sometimes suddenly mortal.
Amid the debris of twisted metal and broken glass lay a briefcase containing 144 handwritten pages of «The First Man.» Crowded handwriting, notes in the margins, sentences sometimes left unpunctuated—the first draft of a major autobiographical work. «The First Man» turned out to be the writer's last novel. The manuscript lay unpublished for 34 years until Camus's daughter, Catherine, deciphered it and passed it on to readers. In a dark and cold world, the living keep the fire burning. They pick up the remaining words and continue their rebellion, not consoling themselves with the thought that the catastrophe contained some higher meaning. The final episode of Camus's biography leads us to the absurd: a man writes the book of his life, and the world, with a single movement, cuts off both the book and his life, without deigning to explain it.
In «The Myth of Sisyphus,» published in 1942, Camus provides one of the most precise formulas for the absurd. The absurd isn't found only in man. Man possesses meaning and strives for it. But the absurd isn't found in the world itself either. The world is meaningless, but not absurd. The spark of the absurd is struck by the clash between a meaningful man and a meaningless world. The absurd is a discord, yet it is the only thing that connects man and the world.
I said the world is absurd, but that was too hasty. The world itself is irrational—that's all that can be said about it. But what's absurd is the clash of this irrationality with the frantic desire for clarity that resounds in the depths of the human heart. Absurdity depends equally on the individual and on the world.
It's not enough for a person to live. They need to understand why they live. It's not enough for them to suffer. They want to know why they suffer. It's not enough for them to die. They demand that death be included in the order of meaning, justice, or redemption. A person is not just an animal caught in the world. They are a being who asks the world a question and awaits an answer. But the world is silent, and this silence is more frightening than any objection. Therefore, the absurd differs from both fear and anxiety. Fear requires an object. Anxiety requires only an absent object, leaving behind an open wound. The absurd arises from inconsistency. Man is rational, but the world is not. Man seeks the whole, but receives disparate fragments. He seeks Truth, but can only count on truths. No single meaning can gather this scattered fragment. For the world to become history, it must be told by a person. But the storyteller knows only too well that his story is not equal to the world itself.
Camus begins The Myth of Sisyphus with a radical thesis:
There is only one truly serious philosophical question—the question of suicide. Deciding whether life is worth living or not is to answer the fundamental question of philosophy.
This phrase often sounds like a catchy aphorism, but for Camus, it has a rigorous meaning. If the world fails to respond to the human demand for meaning, the question arises: is it worth continuing to live? Isn't existence itself a mistake if it lacks any final justification? Here, philosophy ceases to be an armchair discipline. It no longer asks only about categories, methods, and foundations of knowledge. It asks whether one should continue to get up in the morning for work, suffer from unrequited love, and endure the world's silence.
Camus answers the question by rejecting suicide. Suicide destroys not the absurd, but one of its aspects. The absurd rests on the clash between man and the world—if man is eliminated, the clash itself disappears. But for Camus, the important thing is not to extinguish the contradiction, but to endure it. Man must not capitulate to the world's silence, even if he is unable to make it speak. This gives rise to the second danger—what Camus calls philosophical suicide. It is gentler than the physical. Instead of destroying oneself in the world of things, man discards the absurd in the world of ideas, leaping over it to salvific meaning. Philosophical suicide is the rejection of rational understanding of the absurd by turning to philosophical or religious illusions. In Camus's philosophy, there are two main forms of philosophical suicide. The religious «leap of faith» (Kierkegaard, Shestov): man relieves the tragic tension of the absurd by submitting to a higher, incomprehensible reason or by placing his hopes in an afterlife. Reason is sacrificed, and man finds himself deprived of the ability to understand the surrounding world in its essence; in exchange, he is offered a transgressive act of faith. Man acknowledges the collapse of earthly reason and blindly surrenders himself to God. The rational «leap» (Husserl, Jaspers): the tragic tension is relieved by proving the presence of a hidden, salvific meaning in the world. The rationality of the human order is forcibly ascribed to the world. Attributing reason to the world and denying reason to man are two forms of philosophical suicide, and both displease Camus. He believes we must resist both kinds of leaps, enduring the dizziness: «To be able to hold on to this dizzying mountain ridge—that is honesty; everything else is subterfuge.» Camus desires no consolation beyond the grave. His man remains here: beneath the sky, among stones, toil, fatigue, and light, without the guarantee of ultimate meaning.
Yet Camus does not preach despair. His thought is remarkably dry and sunny, like the climate of Algeria, his homeland. The absurd does not demand that one lie down on the ground and declare life a failure. On the contrary, acknowledging the absurd liberates one from false hopes and returns one to life itself. Without a higher justification, life does not become insignificant. It becomes the only field where one can still breathe, act, love, resist, remember, and enjoy. The absurd man does not believe in ultimate salvation, but precisely for this reason he does not postpone life until a future justification. He does not wait for the world to receive meaning from above. Like the condemned Meursault in Camus's novella «The Stranger,» man must open his soul to the «gentle indifference of the world»:
On the threshold of death, my mother probably felt a sense of liberation and a readiness to relive everything. No one, no one had the right to cry over her. And like her, I too feel ready to relive everything. It was as if my recent violent indignation had cleansed me of all malice, banished hope, and, gazing at this night sky, strewn with signs and stars, I opened my soul for the first time to the world's gentle indifference.
This willingness to relive everything does not mean hope for another life. On the eve of his execution, a priest comes to Meursault and offers him confession, but he is refused. He asks to at least be allowed to embrace him, but Meursault refuses even this consolation. Finally, the priest, in despair, asks if the condemned man has never thought about eternal life. He has, Meursault replies, and imagined it as «one in which I could remember my earthly life.» Even eternity has value for him only as a memory of earthly life.
This is how rebellion arises. Rebellion is not a revolutionary program or the romantic waving of a banner over a barricade. It is a stubborn «no» to capitulation. Man does not accept meaninglessness as an excuse to disappear or replace it with a convenient metaphysics. He holds the contradiction open. In this sense, the absurd demands discipline. One must not deceive oneself, not take refuge in self-saving consolation, not pass off wishful thinking as truth. The rebellion of the absurd man consists in fidelity to clarity. For Camus, the figure of Sisyphus becomes the most accurate image of this situation. The gods punish Sisyphus with endless labor: he must roll a stone up a mountain, but the stone falls again and again. At first glance, we see a pure picture of meaninglessness. The work leads to no result, the effort is always nullified. But this is precisely why Sisyphus turns out to be the hero of the absurd. He does not overcome punishment, does not abolish meaninglessness, does not achieve secret salvation. He knows his fate and keeps rolling. The most important moment in the myth is not the ascent, but the descent. While Sisyphus pushes the stone, his body is busy working. But when the stone falls again, Sisyphus descends after it and for a moment is alone with his knowledge. He understands everything. He is not under the illusion that this time the stone will remain on top. He does not wait for the gods' mercy:
Contemplating his own torment, the absurd man silences all idols. And then, in the universe that has suddenly regained its silence, thousands of subtle, wondrous earthly voices become discernible.
The gods control punishment, but they do not control Sisyphus himself. They condemned him to repeat the punishment, but they could not force him to consider it a failure. The stone remains heavy, the mountain remains a mountain, but Sisyphus ceases to be a victim.
One ascent to the summit is enough to fill a person's heart to the brim. Imagine Sisyphus happy.
Camus's famous final thought about the happy Sisyphus shouldn't sound like a life coach's affirmation. It's not the happiness of someone who has achieved what they wanted, nor is it the happiness of reconciling themselves to the meaninglessness of the world. Sisyphus's happiness is austere and ascetic: it is born of a refusal to give the gods the final word. While he rolls the stone, he neither justifies the world nor dissolves into it.
For Camus, the absurd is not anxiety, because it is no longer about inner freedom, finitude, or the discomfort of human existence. But it is also not horror in the strict sense. For Camus, the world does not transform into a Great Outside, inhuman and unthinkable. It does not intrude like a cosmic abyss and does not destroy thought with its disproportion. It simply does not respond. The absurd arises at the boundary between man and world: not within the subject or the object itself, but between the human demand for meaning and external silence. It is not fear of threat, not anxiety before one's own possibility, and not horror before the unthinkable. It is the pain of incompatibility: man is constituted in such a way that he must question, and the world is constituted in such a way that it cannot answer. This is precisely why the absurd is closest to the fear of incompatibility. In the abject, as we will see later, what is frightening is the mixing of what should not be mixed. In the absurd, something else is frightening: the impossibility of combining what man needs to combine. Reason desires a world that can be understood. The world is silent. Man desires a life that can be justified. Life is what it is. Man desires a death filled with meaning. Death is sudden and meaningless. There is no harmony between them, but there is no complete rupture either. Man remains in a world that does not respond to him, and continues to push the stone.
